We had our Scenario game last night, everyone had fun (except maybe NY). Jonah and I took the confederate II and III Corps respectively while NY and Soldier took the I and XI Corps. We played some scenario that LP created.
From what I could see, the I Corps was massacred. The divisions of Rodes, Pettigrew, and Pender just overran it in the hour long battle, inflicting 700 more casualties than they took and utterly clobbering any troops that attempted to stand on MacPherson's and Seminary Ridges.
Soldier and the XI Corps managed to stave off an even more crushing defeat by revenging their name from Chancellorsville. Soldier managed to hold the line against Early's division and retreated to town in good order at the end of the battle.
In terms of the scenario, LP probably needed to take out Pettigrew's entire division or delay Pender's (hide it) and attribute casualties to Archer's and Davis's Brigades because I just massed 8 Confederate brigades and charged them in column formation up McPherson's Ridge, just demolishing the three brigades in my path. I mean, 10000+ troops against 4000 with some artillery? It really just isn't fair for the Federals.
But it was good fun. Who knows, maybe we should have been commanding in the Civil War. The Confederates were just about set to take Cemetary Hill.