Re: An observation on fatigue
Posted: Thu Dec 23, 2010 8:15 pm
We know that, they don't get tired from walking much unless uphill or in rough terrain. We're talking about running. They can run almost halfway across the map without stopping, and then lay down and rest, and be fully recovered before troops that were marching that distance arrive.
Now, even if individuals could run that distance in real life, there would certainly be some downside to running entire regiments for a whole mile. Certainly troops that ran the mile would not be completely recovered from it in less time than it would take to walk the mile.
Edit:
Here's the data from a test I just did.
I had two regiments cross 3/4 of the Kansas map. They started at the same time, 12:02:30 PM. One of them ran the entire distance, the other walked the entire distance. Neither regiment stopped or turned along the way at all.
The times shown below are Minutes:Seconds.
The running regiment arrived at the destination at 15:05 PM, a total running time of 12:35. They immediately started resting, and at 20:15 (5:10 resting time) they were fully rested. The marching regiment arrived at 24:30, a total marching time of 22:30.
So it took 1065 seconds for the running regiment to cross the distance and fully rest.
It took 1350 seconds for the walking regiment to cross the distance arrive.
Therefore it took 4/5 the time to run the entire distance and then fully rest. So why walk at all, unless you're very close to the enemy and don't want any fatigue when you arrive?
Now, even if individuals could run that distance in real life, there would certainly be some downside to running entire regiments for a whole mile. Certainly troops that ran the mile would not be completely recovered from it in less time than it would take to walk the mile.
Edit:
Here's the data from a test I just did.
I had two regiments cross 3/4 of the Kansas map. They started at the same time, 12:02:30 PM. One of them ran the entire distance, the other walked the entire distance. Neither regiment stopped or turned along the way at all.
The times shown below are Minutes:Seconds.
The running regiment arrived at the destination at 15:05 PM, a total running time of 12:35. They immediately started resting, and at 20:15 (5:10 resting time) they were fully rested. The marching regiment arrived at 24:30, a total marching time of 22:30.
So it took 1065 seconds for the running regiment to cross the distance and fully rest.
It took 1350 seconds for the walking regiment to cross the distance arrive.
Therefore it took 4/5 the time to run the entire distance and then fully rest. So why walk at all, unless you're very close to the enemy and don't want any fatigue when you arrive?