Scourge of War Boards

I play mostly Single Player. I see almost only line formation when Enemy-AI controlled troops move around on the battlefield. This results after 10 Minutes of almost each scenario (sandbox or waterloo) in overlapping lines, battalion lines changing forming rings(!), and wheeling when engaged very often. This really kills immersion for me and makes the game not at all enjoyable to play.
Question: Can I change the AI behaviour by modding so that it uses column in division almost all the time, only when very close to the enemy it tries to form a line, can I prevent it from wheeling very quickly too?

I would think of something like the following examples:
- French Line Infantry, non-road movement not under threat: use formation
in column of division.
- English Guards Reaction time (start of wheeling) after discovery of new thread x seconds.
- French Light Inf wheeling time for n degrees : x seconds.
- Inf Fire value of Inf in column of division = 1/3 rd strength.
Then I would be pleased.
When do you plan to release the SDK ?

We are working on it now but have a bit of a pause to help out with the new players and issues not seen in testing.

The first may be possible but will need testing. Mitra will have to comment on the middle three items. Currently the attack columns are not set to fight. That can be modded but I am not sure how the fire strength would be represented in that odd case. My understanding is that while the French moved in collone d'attaque they rarely fought out of that formation unless surprised due to the major firepower penalty.

-Jim

Question: Can I change the AI behaviour by modding so that it uses column in division almost all the time, only when very close to the enemy it tries to form a line, can I prevent it from wheeling very quickly too?

yes, is possible but you will need to study well before the current flow and parametrical tables in order to "hit" well where you want change in the code

- French Line Infantry, non-road movement not under threat: use formation
in column of division.

For this you can change in the unitglobal.csv the current column march formation used with the other

- English Guards Reaction time (start of wheeling) after discovery of new thread x seconds.
- French Light Inf wheeling time for n degrees : x seconds.
- Inf Fire value of Inf in column of division = 1/3 rd strength.

Yes (but the wheeling time necessary to wheel no, it is related to unit speed movement is not controlled from the AI, the AI simply order to wheel or not, you can use a switch variable in order to delay it in rapport to the gametime at example or a loop yes a loop no) but AI specialized for formation type will request you to create many new routines and unit types. If you like coding I think you will have a lot of fun with this, like I had.

Yes (but the wheeling time necessary to wheel no, it is related to unit speed movement is not controlled from the AI, the AI simply order to wheel or not.

So this was changed, the drills.csv file no longer controls whether a unit can \ cannot wheel?

Thanks,

davinci

Davide was referring to the speed of wheeling which can't be controlled by the AI mod system. However, it could be by changing the run speed, a no no I would think. Regarding Drills nothing has changed that I can think of, except the formations of course. So yes, one can go in and zero the column 'can wheel' on all the line formations, if they dare. Sure would put the AI at a disadvantage though because the player could still use the new 'pivot from the flank' commands located on the Grog Toolbar.

OK, Thanks Reb !

Davide was referring to the speed of wheeling which can't be controlled by the AI mod system. However, it could be by changing the run speed, a no no I would think.

Well, if not too much as changed, that is probably true. I have always played the game at a slower-movement rate and the wheeling \ turning of the regiments has always been very slow, so it has to be related to the movement speed.

davinci

Yes (but the wheeling time necessary to wheel no, it is related to unit speed movement is not controlled from the AI, the AI simply order to wheel or not.

So this was changed, the drills.csv file no longer controls whether a unit can \ cannot wheel?

Thanks,

davinci

Now I'm in the office I cannot check, but I don't remember a parameter to block the wheeling in drills.csv; there's a wheeling locked in unitattributes.csv which determine a minimal distance respect the nearest enemy and was checked inside the AI also in Gettysburg, in Waterloo I used it also.

Column I - Can Wheel

Its a good point that the battalion 'attack column' (column of divisions) was only used to close the distance with the enemy - despite perhaps what the adventures of Dick Sharpe may lead us to believe the French doctrine was to deploy into line when they had closed to within musket range

There is a problem at the moment with the AI using line formations far too much and frankly it cannot handle them very well leading to the mess we see at the moment.
Perhaps the AI should be set to use column of divisions up until the point when it is <200 yards from an enemy and them switch to line.

Column I - Can Wheel

I see, this is checked in the hardcoded part implicitly in all the wheel commands also given from the users, so also if I give the order the formation will not wheel